At a glance
- There is no seven-second rule, or any other safe length, in US, EU or Italian copyright law.
- In Pelham the Court of Justice held that even a two-second sample engages the rightholder’s exclusive right.
- In Italy a short clip can be lawful only under a specific exception, such as quotation for criticism (Article 70), and moral rights still apply. When in doubt, license.
Last updated: October 2026, by Avv. Claudia Roggero, entertainment and copyright lawyer, Rome Bar since 2003.
“Under seven seconds you don’t need permission.” Every editor has heard it. It is not true: not in the United States, not in the European Union and not in Italy. No court has ever recognised a safe length for using someone else’s work, and believing in one has cost producers real money. In the leading European case the sample at issue lasted two seconds, and it still needed the rightholder’s consent.
This guide explains where the myth comes from, what US, EU and Italian law actually say, and how to handle short clips in a production.
Where the myth comes from
The rule seems to have grown out of a loose reading of American fair use cases and the working habits of television newsrooms and documentary editors. Passed from editor to editor, a rough habit turned into something that sounded like law. It comes in several versions, five seconds, ten seconds, thirty, but they all share the same idea: that below a certain length an unauthorised use becomes lawful. It never does.
The myth survives because it is often right about what happens and wrong about why. Most short uses are never challenged, not because they are lawful but because nobody notices or nobody bothers. That is a risk you are taking, not a right you have, and it disappears as soon as the film becomes commercially visible.
The United States: Hirsch v. CBS
In Hirsch v. CBS Broadcasting (S.D.N.Y. 2017), a copyrighted photograph appeared briefly in a CBS news broadcast. CBS argued that the use was so short that it was either fair use or too trivial to matter. The court refused to dismiss the claim on either ground. Fair use under 17 U.S.C. § 107 depends on four factors, the purpose of the use, the nature of the work, the amount used and the effect on the market, and the amount used is only one of them. A brief use can still fail the test if the other factors weigh against it. Fair use is a case-by-case doctrine, which is exactly why it cannot produce a fixed number of seconds.
The European Union: Pelham and the two-second sample
The European version of the question reached the Court of Justice in Pelham v. Hütter (C-476/17, 29 July 2019), over a two-second sample of Kraftwerk’s Metall auf Metall. The Court held that reproducing even a very short sample of a recording is a reproduction that requires the producer’s consent. Only a sample modified so much that it is no longer recognisable to the ear falls outside that right. There is no exemption based on length.
Pelham also settled a wider point. It rejected the German doctrine of “free use” and confirmed that the exceptions in EU copyright law are a closed list: there is no general fairness standard to fall back on.
Italy: a closed list of exceptions
Italian law has exceptions that can cover a short clip, but none of them depends on length.
- Quotation for criticism, discussion or teaching (Article 70 of the Copyright Act). Parts of a work may be quoted or reproduced for criticism or discussion, within the limits justified by that purpose, without competing with the economic exploitation of the work and with proper attribution. This is the exception most often relevant to clips.
- News reporting (Article 65). Reporting of current events of general interest, with its own conditions.
- Parody, caricature and pastiche. An autonomous concept of EU law, defined by the Court of Justice in Deckmyn v. Vandersteen (C-201/13, 2014): the new work must evoke the original while being noticeably different, and express humour or mockery. Italian law codifies this exception only for users uploading content to online platforms (Article 102-nonies, introduced in 2021). Outside that context, Italian courts assess parody case by case, mainly through Article 70 and a balance with freedom of expression, as the Court of Cassation did in December 2022.
Each exception requires an assessment of purpose, proportion, attribution and economic impact. A seven-second clip may qualify under one of them, or may not. What really decides the outcome is how long the extract is compared with the whole work and whether it is its most recognisable part; whether the programme genuinely comments on the clip or just uses it as illustration; whether the use is commercial; and whether it could replace the original. Two clips of the same length from the same film can end up on opposite sides of the line, depending on how the programme treats them.
The layer nobody budgets for: moral rights
In Italy, passing the economic test does not end the risk. Moral rights cannot be waived, and after the author’s death they can be exercised by the heirs without time limit. A clip that qualifies as a quotation can still lead to a claim if the way it is used distorts the work or harms the author’s honour or reputation. Satirical and recontextualising uses are the most exposed, precisely because they are the ones most likely to rely on the quotation exception. A US fair use memo does not cover this, and it is the most common gap in clearance advice prepared outside Italy.
Platforms act before the law does
Online platforms are directly liable for what users upload under the EU Digital Single Market rules, and they rely on automatic content recognition. Those systems identify protected material whatever its length and block or monetise it automatically. You can raise an exception on appeal, but only after the restriction has taken effect. For a film with a release window, that delay can be the real cost, whatever the legal analysis says.
How to handle short clips in practice
- Do not rely on any fixed length.
- Identify which exception could apply, if any: quotation, news reporting, parody, US fair use.
- Assess all the factors, not just duration: purpose, proportion, market impact and attribution.
- Assess moral rights separately whenever the clip is altered, satirised or placed in a new context.
- License when the position is uncertain. A short licence is usually cheap compared with the risk it removes, and far cheaper than the same licence negotiated after a claim.
- Document your reasoning: insurers ask for the analysis, not just the conclusion.
- For online release, expect content recognition and leave time in the schedule for appeals.
How DANDI.media can help
We advise producers on short clips from pre-production to release: clearance strategy, written clip-by-clip assessments under Article 70, the parody framework and Pelham, with a recommended action for each clip; music sampling clearance; news and documentary clip licences; moral rights analysis; platform appeals; and defence against infringement claims. Foreign law firms regularly instruct us on the Italian-law side of a wider clearance. Our clip clearance service in Italy explains how we work.
To discuss a project, book a consultation or write to claudiaroggero@dandi.media.
FAQ
Is there a seven-second rule in copyright law?
No. There is no seven-second rule in US, EU or Italian copyright law, and no court has recognised a safe length. Versions citing five, ten or thirty seconds are equally unfounded.
How short can a clip be before it stops infringing?
There is no such threshold. In Pelham the Court of Justice held that a two-second sample of a recording engages the producer’s exclusive right. Length is one factor in assessing an exception, not a safe harbour.
Does fair use protect short clips in the United States?
Only if the four-factor analysis supports it. In Hirsch v. CBS Broadcasting the court refused to treat a brief use as automatically fair or trivial.
Which exception applies to clips in Italy?
Most often quotation for criticism or discussion under Article 70 of the Copyright Act, within the limits of that purpose, with attribution and without competing with the work’s exploitation. News reporting and parody follow their own rules.
Is there a parody exception in Italian law?
Only for users uploading content to online platforms (Article 102-nonies). In other cases Italian courts assess parody case by case, mainly through the quotation exception and freedom of expression.
Can moral rights be a problem even if the clip use is lawful?
Yes. In Italy moral rights cannot be waived and can be exercised by heirs. A lawful quotation can still lead to a claim if the treatment distorts the work or harms the author’s reputation.
Should I license a short clip even if I think an exception applies?
Often yes. A short licence is usually inexpensive, and it removes both the legal uncertainty and the platform risk. If you go ahead without one, document your analysis.
Related guides
| Topic | Link |
|---|---|
| Clip clearance in Italy | DANDI.media service |
| Clearing copyrighted material | DANDI.media guide |
| Chain of title documents checklist | DANDI.media guide |
| Moral rights in film | DANDI.media guide |
| Public domain in Italy | DANDI.media guide |
| Music synchronisation contract | DANDI.media guide |
| Copyright law in Italy and Europe | DANDI.media guide |
This guide reflects the law at the date above. Check the current rules before relying on it for a specific production.
Dandi Law Firm provides legal assistance in several Practice Areas. Check out our Services or contact Us!


